A Family Decision Game: How to Pick Dinner, Movies and Weekend Plans Everyone Can Live With

By Kirill Zubovsky · · 5 min read

"What do you want for dinner?" "I don't know. What do you want?" "I don't care. You pick." Sound familiar? Family decisions stall in the same few ways: the loudest voice wins, or nobody commits and everyone ends up with takeout nobody was excited about.

The good news is that a few simple rules fix most of it. Below is a ten-minute family decision game that works for dinner, movie night, weekend plans, and even choosing a pet's name. It uses private rankings so quiet people get a real say, and a points system that finds the option everyone can live with, which is often better than the one person's first choice.

Why family decisions get stuck

A game fixes this because the rules are agreed before anyone knows who will win.

The rules of the game

  1. Name the question. Say it out loud: "What should we do on Saturday?" A clear question gives clear answers.
  2. Build a short list together. Aim for four to seven options. Each person adds one idea, and each person gets one veto, but you can't veto your own idea.
  3. Everyone ranks privately. Each person plays their own this-or-that round. In Sortpair that takes about a minute: you get two options at a time and pick one. For five options it is usually six or seven picks. Pass one device around, or use several, and don't comment while someone else is playing.
  4. Add up the points. A first place earns the most points and last place earns one. Add each person's points for each option (the worked example is below).
  5. Announce the winner. The highest total wins. If it's a tie, flip a coin or let the youngest player pick.
  6. Honor the result. Everyone agreed to the rules, so the winner happens. The runner-up goes first next time.

A worked example

Three people are choosing Saturday's plan from four options: bike ride, movie night, playground and board games. Each person ranks them privately. With four options, 1st place earns 4 points, 2nd earns 3, 3rd earns 2 and 4th earns 1.

OptionMomDadKidTotal
🚲 Bike ride4217
🎬 Movie night1427
🛝 Playground2147
🎲 Board games3339

Look at what happened. Nobody picked board games as their first choice. Each of the other three options was somebody's favorite, and somebody else's last place. But board games was everyone's second choice, so it finished on top with 9 points. That's the "everyone can live with it" winner.

This points method is a classic way to combine rankings. It rewards options that are broadly liked, not just options that are loved by one person. It isn't the only fair way to count, and that makes a good family conversation: would you rather the plan that most people ranked first, or the plan nobody dislikes? Agree which you want before you play.

Why kids love it (and what they learn)

Ready-made lineups to try

Sortpair has quick lineups you can load in one tap and edit:

Common problems and easy fixes

"It's not fair, my pick lost!"

Remind everyone that they agreed to the rules first. Then use the runner-up rule: the second-place option gets priority next time.

One person always picks the same kind of thing.

That's useful information, not a flaw. Let that person suggest the list one week, so the options match their taste.

The adults keep taking over.

Have the kids rank first and privately. Adults shouldn't comment on anyone's picks until the totals are in.

There are too many options.

Cap it at seven. If you have more, run one round to find the top five, then run the real vote on those.

Someone just wants to be done.

Keep the whole thing under ten minutes, and tell everyone the time limit up front. Short rounds beat long debates.

When not to vote

A game is great for low-stakes choices like dinner, movies and weekend plans. It isn't the right tool for decisions about safety, health, money or big family changes. Those need listening, not tallying. You can still use the ranking as one input to the conversation.

Frequently asked questions

How many people can play?

As many as you like, since each person plays their own round. For two or three people it's quick; for a big holiday table, give everyone one minute and tally on paper.

Do we need a phone for each person?

No. Pass one device around. Press Copy list after each round and paste it into a notes app, so the totals are easy to add up.

Does it cost anything or need an account?

No. Sortpair is free, and there's no sign-up. Your list stays in your browser.

What if two options tie?

Use a coin flip, or let the youngest person break the tie. Whatever you choose, agree on it before you play.

Curious how the picks add up to a full ranking behind the scenes? Read how to rank any list by picking two at a time.

More from the Sortpair blog